Judging a book by its cover
By Leslie Budewitz
“Don’t judge a book by its cover.” As a metaphor, it’s spot-on: Don’t judge the interior by the exterior; don’t assume you know a person’s nature—their heart, mind, and values—by their appearance.
When it comes to actual books, though, we do it all the time. And it’s not a bad way to make that first decision—“Is this a book I’m likely to enjoy?” Occasionally, there’s a miss—a cat prances across the cover of a book with no felines, or the cover shows a bridge that appeared in a previous draft only to be demolished by the wrecking ball of later edits.
But in the world of the light-hearted mystery, the cover works hard. It cues us in to the protagonist’s occupation and where she spends most of her time, conveys the mood of the story, and may offer clues to the central conflict. Food, pets, and even the murder weapon are common elements.
I love hearing reader compliments about my covers. While I adore them all, ASSAULT AND PEPPER may be my favorite cover yet. My publisher, Berkley Prime Crime, part of Penguin Random House, contracts with artists who have a magical ability to convey our story worlds in pictures. (Both my series are illustrated by the same artist.) Authors provide images and a description of key locations— the cover of the first book in a series usually showcases the protagonist’s shop, library, or bakery, while later covers illustrate a location that features in the story. The artist may also read a draft, or at the least, a synopsis.
The cover of ASSAULT AND PEPPER takes us inside Pepper Reece’s Seattle Spice Shop, with the Pike Place Market visible through the open door and window. Shelves brim with spice jars. Pepper’s collection of antique grinders and spice boxes can be seen on the shelves beneath the front counter, and the pseudo-samovar the staff uses to serve sample cups of tea sits on a vintage tea cart Pepper snatched up on a junking trip with her BFF, Kristen. Both the samovar and the sample cups—a few are littered on the floor—are critical to the story.
And so, of course, is Arf the dog, who comes alive on the cover. It’s been great fun to see how my artist works Mr. Sandburg, Erin Murphy’s Burmese cat, into the covers of the Food Lovers’ Village Mysteries. He lives at home with her, not in the shop, but there he is on the cover of DEATH AL DENTE, demonstrating both his cuteness and his influence over Erin. On the cover of CRIME RIB, he and Pepé, his dog-in-law, join Duke the Retriever, who belongs to one of the chefs competing in the steak grill-off, for a romp on the stone patio of Caldwell’s Eagle Lake Lodge. The lodge is the scene of both festivities and crime. In BUTTER OFF DEAD (coming July 2015), Mr. Sandburg takes in a movie, presiding over a concession stand brimming with the over-the-top treats typical of the Food Lovers’ books. The artist even worked in the movie posters that play a role in the story. And if you look closely, you’ll see another cat ….
My artist, Ben Perini, illustrates covers in other styles as well—he’s done covers for J.A. Jance, literary novelists, and even nonfiction. He’s also a fine artist who calls himself “a professional dreamer.” His covers are your invitation to enter the world of my dreams and play for a while.
So, welcome—come on in.
About the Author:
Leslie Budewitz is the author of the Spice Shop Mysteries and the Food Lovers Village Mysteries, both from Berkley Prime Crime. She is the only author to win Agatha Awards for both fiction and nonfiction—the 2013 Agatha Award for Best First Novel, for Death al Dente and the 2011 Agatha Award for Best Nonfiction, for Books, Crooks & Counselors: How to Write Accurately About Criminal Law & Courtroom Procedure (Quill Driver Books). She lives in northwest Montana with her husband, a musician and doctor of natural medicine, and their cat Ruff, a cover model and avid bird-watcher.
From the cover of ASSAULT AND PEPPER:
Pepper Reece, owner of the Seattle Spice Shop, thinks she can handle any kind of salty customer—until a murderer ends up in the mix…
After leaving a dicey marriage and losing a beloved job in a corporate crash, Pepper Reece has found a new zest for life running a busy spice and tea shop in Seattle’s Pike Place Market. Her aromatic creations are the talk of the town, and everyone stops by for a cup of her refreshing spice tea, even other shopkeepers and Market regulars.
But when a panhandler named Doc shows up dead on her doorstep, a Seattle Spice Shop cup in his hand, the local gossip gets too hot for Pepper to handle—especially after the police arrest Tory Finch, one of Pepper’s staffers, for murder.
Tory seems to know why she’s a suspect, but she refuses to do anything to curry favor with the cops. Convinced her reticent employee is innocent, Pepper takes it on herself to sniff out some clues. Only, if she’s not careful, Pepper’s nosy ways might make her next on the killer’s list…
Jennifer’s Review of Assault and Pepper
Review (4.5 Stars): Pepper Reece is the owner of the Seattle Spice Shop in the lovely Pike Place Market and life is slowly coming together for her when she discovers a body of a homeless man on the shop’s front doorstep. Pepper recognizes the panhandler from her interaction with him the day before and believes that the man simply died from natural causes. Soon, she discovers that the police believe that the man was murdered and one of her employees has been arrested for the crime. Pepper knows that she is innocent and decides that she needs to find some clues before an innocent woman is put away for a crime she didn’t commit.
I loved Pepper and the gang at Seattle Spice Shop. Pike Place Market has always been one of my favorite places to visit when I’m in Seattle and Ms. Budewitz has done a wonderful job of putting you right there with Pepper and savoring the ambiance that is the Market. I enjoyed learning about Pepper’s shop and the different spices that she had available for her customers. These characters are an absolute delight to spend time with and Assault and Pepper has the perfect aroma of mystery that is sure to be a delicious treat to cozy readers. Can’t wait to see what Pepper and the gang are up to in the next installment of this series.
Giveaway
I love this writer’s work—can’t wait to read Assault and Pepper!
Love the title; looks great and thank you for the chance to win it 🙂
jslbrown2009(at)aol(dot)com
Since I do all the shopping and cooking in the house I’ve developed a nose for new spices. There’s also the fact that you need to turn over your spice rack every year and replace old spices. So I think this new series will be very interesting. I would love to be your lucky winner.
Have just started reading Leslie, and already excited about Butter Off Dead. Keep them coming. I am totally a COZY MYSTERY ADDICT especially any with FOOD AND ANIMALS. Can’t get enough. Do I need REHAB?????? I could read books all day and WITH DRAW slowly….very slowly………
Thanks to all of you for the comments, and to Jennifer for the lovely review. This may be my favorite cover so far, and I hope you all my story people and their adventures as much as I do!
I love the food lover’s village series, so I’m sure that I will love this series too. I can’t wait to read about the spice shop.
momzillasteel at gmail dot com
Can’t wait to start this one. Thanks for giving me a chance to win. So many books and not enough time. Holy Smokes.
Have a great day.
I was hooked after her first book, love to win this one!
I love the covers anea d would buy jigsaw puzzles of them if they were available. In this case the artist and writer make a great team for writing cozies. Another cozy addict!
Great idea, Carol. I started to look into it once but got sidetracked. Might be time to check it out again!
I absolutely love the cover of this book. I can very much relate to having a puppy standing in the middle of a mess on the floor.
Great review of this book. Reading your write up on this book makes me want to read it even more!
And thanks for posting the cover for the latest food lovers village mystery as well. I love that series and can’t wait to read the next one in it.
The book covers definately draw you in to read the book. Kudos to the designers! They have to be good to live up to the stories. Wish I had them all!!
Would love a chance to read this. Thank you for a chance!
I think I would love this book!!
Great post! It’s so true that cover are important to cozies. Sometimes I get in such a hurry to read the story that I don’t take enough time with the cover. I go back and look carefully because there are so many clues or references to things within the story. These series have been on my TBR for too long – need to be moved to the top! Thanks for the giveaway.
Sally, I’ve got a 16X20 poster of the cover that the publisher, Berkley Prime Crime/Penguin, sent for each book, and when I look at the big size, I see even more detail. Ben really gets the spirit of these books!
Can’t wait to read this; I just love your books, each time I read them they seem so real, how you describe everything on the book. Tks, for giveaway.
Lovely review. This is on my TBR list so thank you for the giveaway!
Covers are so important to cozies—first of all they tell you it’s a cozy so you should pick it up and check it out.
Thanks for the giveaway.
suefarrell.farrell@gmail.com
Thanks to all of you for celebrating with me!
I’m really looking forward to reading “Assault and Pepper”. Thank you very much for the chance to win!
I love the area around the Pike Market and the name of this book is terribly clever. I do so love covers and this one is a pip of a cover.
Assault and Pepper is on my TBR list because the book just sounds like a great read. Thank you for the review and giveaway. 🙂
myrifraf(at)gmail(dot)com
Looking forward to reading Assault and Pepper. It sounds like a great beginning to what I’m sure will be a great new series. Thanks for the chance to win.
Thank you Leslie for introducing your artist and filling us in on the process for your cover art. So much goes on behind the scenes.
I am so looking forward to reading the debut of your Spice Shop Mysteries. Thank you for taking the time to visit today and thank you too Jennifer for the review and the opportunity for one of us to win a copy of Assault and Pepper.
sxygrndma48{at}yahoo{dot}come
Pike Place Market–what a wonderful spot for considering a dead body. More! More!
This sounds wonderful! Can’t wait to read! Thanks for the chance.
I would love to read this book! I do like the cover art on Assault and Pepper; it is one of the things that appeals to me about the book. The tea sets, antique urn, and dog are, to me, the most appealing and give the book character. 🙂 Congrats on your book release date!!! jeaniedannheim (at) ymail (dot) com
Ah, the urn and the dog — stay tuned! Key players, both! Thanks, Jeanie!
Thanks for this great giveaway and wonderful feature. Congratulations and best wishes.
I’ve been looking forward to this book! I really like the cover and the interesting ins and outs of how they come together. I bet it’s unusual for Leslie to have the same artist for both series. Thanks for the chance to win!
Good question, and I honestly don’t know if other authors with multiple series from the same publisher get the same artist or not. A quick scan inside covers on my shelves didn’t answer the question. I feel very lucky!
Leslie is one among the many cozy mystery writers that I enjoy. I’ve been waiting for this one to be released. Thanks for the opportunity to win a copy.
I love the title and cover of the book. Would love to read it. Thanks for the giveaway opportunity.
I love trying new series from the beginning. Thanks for the review and giveaway opportunity.
Looks like a great cozy mystery.
I am so excited for this series. It sounds like a wonderful mystery! Thank you for sharing your review.
Leslie is a new to me author. I enjoyed the guest post and agree that with a cozy mystery – the cover really is very important. I love the cover for Assault and Pepper and look forward to reading a copy of this book soon – thanks for the giveaway
Thanks for the review, synopsis, and the article on judging books by their covers. . I am interested in reading this book…the spice shop with amuerder mystery.
It sounds like a fun and spicy mystery. I love the characters. Thanks for having the giveaway.
Thanks to all of you for stopping by and sharing your view of cozy covers! I hope you enjoy the trip to Seattle — on the page — as much as I enjoy taking you there!
I have not read any other books by this author, but I love the Pike Place Market, and I love to go there when I visit Seattle.
funny blurb
This book is on my short list of TBRs. I can’t wait to read it. 😀
I’m looking forward to reading “Assault and Pepper”…congrats, Leslie!
I’d love to start reading this series! It sounds like one I would enjoy! Thank you for the giveaway!
Thanks to all of you for visiting the blog. I hope you enjoy the trip to Seattle — on the page — as much as I enjoyed taking you there!